Rather than get to the bullpen thoughts from Hector Berrios this post, I figured I’d change things up a bit and share my thoughts on the play of the Brooklyn infielders this season.
Note- These are for players that either spent the majority of the season in Brooklyn or are important prospects worth watching. Considering how many shortstops this team had this season alone, this post could be longer than the declaration of independence.
Matt Smith- .198 BA, 2 HR 9 RBI- Despite his low batting average, Smith was a solid leader in the clubhouse, played adequate defense and drew a ton of walks before injuries derailed his season. With a host of players making the jump to the bigs this season in Binghamton and Smith already having some AA experience, he figures to start the season there.
Grade- C
JR Voyles- .223 BA, 3 HR, 15 RBI- Last season’s cult hero couldn’t cut the mustard in his second season in Brooklyn and it was easy to see that he wasn’t the same player. His defense wasn’t as sharp either, as several errors cost the team games down the stretch. However, if my memory does serve me correctly, the team won 29 of their 45 games after he was called up in mid-July, making him their honorary good luck charm. It’s still unknown how much his play had to do with that success though.
Grade- D+
Jose Jimenez- .212 BA, 4 HR, 16 RBI- He started off so strong, but ended abysmally, hitting .081 in his last 37 ABs. His 42 strikeouts in only 136 ABs were also a huge detriment to the team, going along with a less than mediocre .272 OBP. However, his power is still solid enough to land him at higher levels and if he can be a bit more selective at the plate, he can still develop into a solid infielder.
Grade- D
Ike Davis- .256 BA, 0 HR, 17 RBI- Joining the team after the first week of the season, Davis was supposed to be the team’s savior on offense. However, things just never materialized. Even with a .368 average through his last ten games, Davis was still a huge disappointment at the plate. Nevertheless, after a long college season, the youngster may need some rest. During the season, Davis also admitted he had a rib injury that was bothering him when he swung. With that being said, next season seems to look like the real test for Davis, as his time in Brooklyn will be remembered as mediocre. Aside from his less than stellar play at the plate however, Davis was something to behold on defense, making sensational plays all season, somewhat making up for his ineffective bat.
Grade- D
Reese Havens- .247 BA, 3 HR, 12 RBI- While 12 RBI in only 85 ABs isn’t too shabby for a guy tormented by injuries all season, everyone in the press box at Keyspan knew that Havens wasn’t himself, as he was dealing with injuries to his elbow and his groin all season. In spite of that, his patience at the plate and ability to hit in the gaps at Keyspan Park makes you think that once he’s healthy, he’ll be a more than adequate run producer.
Grade- B
Juan Legares- .250 BA, 1 HR, 7 RBI- Kind of hard to argue with 18 hits in 19 games for a 19-year-old in his second season of pro ball. His smarts on the base paths and rocket arm are also going to be fun to watch once he develops. In spite of all of that however, he needs to develop more patience at the plate before he can really show what he is capable of.
Grade B-
Eric Campbell- .260 BA. 4 HR, 28 RBI- One of the team’s most dependable bats this season, Campbell was unable to stay hot for a long period of time and had the epitome of a roller coaster season at the plate, hitting under .200 in September. It’s hard to knock his .313 BA and 23 RBI with runners in scoring position however and his dependable, but not flashy defense. His ability to play decent left field and sneakily solid speed may also increase his stock as his career progresses.
Grade- B
Josh Satin- .280 BA, 4 HR, 13 RBI- Another guy that was dependable whenever he was in the lineup and someone that could have benefited from his teammates being able to get on base a little bit more. Injuries however caused him to be miss a ton of time, and it felt like he was lost in the shuffle for a big part of the season as the team was trying to find it’s offensive identity. As it turns out, while many thought Satin was replaceable at second base, he ended up with the highest BA among players appearing in over 40 games. Steady on defense, the former All-American looks to have an interesting future ahead of him.
Grade- B+
Zach Lutz- .333 BA, 3 HR, 12 RBI- If this guy remained healthy all season, he was easily the team’s MVP on offense, maybe the league. A warrior at the plate and on the field, Lutz was also playing at 70-75 percent the entire season, making you wonder how effective he could have been if he’d be able to run more on his injured foot. 2009 will be an important season for him and it’ll be interesting to see where he ends up in the organization.
Grade- A
Wilmer Flores- 267. BA, O HR, 1 RBI- He started off uber solid in his first few games, but then showed an inability to hold his own against pitchers with more than a fastball. However, with his smooth and compact swing and some more experience, Flores may find himself on the fast track to the big leagues. His defense also could use a bit more polish as his lanky body was making up for instinctual mistakes that just don’t happen with older players. Some time at instructs and another summer in A ball may be the best step in his development as well, perhaps splitting time at Savannah and St. Lucie.
Grade B+
Photos by Ron Hatcher.